Claims Manager

About the job

We are seeking a motivated and detail-oriented Level 1 Claims Manager to lead a team of claims professionals responsible for timely investigation, coverage analysis, liability assessment, and claim resolution. This leader will oversee day-to-day operations, ensure quality and compliance, support adjuster development, and help drive a positive customer experience.

The Level 1 Claims Manager is responsible for supervising a team of claim representatives who investigate, evaluate, and resolve auto and/or casualty claims. This role ensures the team delivers timely, accurate, and customer-focused claim handling while maintaining compliance with company policies and regulatory requirements. The manager oversees workflow distribution, quality control, employee development, risk escalation, and operational performance.

Along with competitive salary, Amwins Specialty Auto offers a full range of benefits including insurance, retirement, and educational reimbursement programs. Amwins Specialty Auto is part of Amwins Group, the largest specialty broker in the United States, with over $14 billion of premium.

This is an in office-position with the option for a hy brid schedule once training is complete.

Responsibilities:

• Oversee daily claim assignments and ensure timely first contact with all relevant parties.

• Monitor investigations, coverage analyses, and liability decisions for accuracy and completeness.

• Review claim documentation to ensure compliance with company standards and regulatory requirements.

• Coach and develop team members to strengthen investigation quality, communication, and negotiation skills.

• Maintain oversight of reserves throughout the life of the claim; ensure appropriate adjustments are made.

• Ensure timely escalation of potential fraud, severity concerns, recovery opportunities, or complex issues.

• Collaborate with material damage units, injury adjusters, and internal partners to support smooth claim handling.

• Track and report team performance metrics, including timeliness, cycle time, reserve adequacy, quality results, and customer satisfaction.

• Support escalated customer or stakeholder concerns, providing clear explanations of decisions. Promote a positive, high-performing team culture focused on service excellence and continuous improvement.

Qualifications:

• 3–5 years of experience in personal auto claims, including Bodily Injury (BI), liability, and physical damage.

• 1-3 years of management experience

• Must be fluent in English, fluent in Spanish is preferred

• Bachelor’s degree or above

• Must have current/active Texas adjuster’s license

• Must obtain Florida adjusters license after hire

• Strong understanding of claim investigations, coverage evaluation, liability assessment, and resolution tactics

• Ability to make sound decisions and guide team members through complex or sensitive claims

• Excellent communication, coaching, and leadership skills

• Strong organizational and time-management skills

• Detail oriented approach with a commitment to accuracy and regulatory compliance.

The Amwins Advantage: Benefits & Perks

• Medical, Dental, Vision available your first day of employment

• Choice of medical plans through Blue Cross Blue Shield; Kaiser available for CA employees

• Mental health support including:

• Virtual therapy

• Digital coaching

• 24/7 EAP counseling

• Company-paid Basic Life & AD&D Insurance, Short-Term Disability, and Employee Assistance Program

• Health Savings Account with company contributions

• Health Care FSA, Dependent Care FSA, and Commuter Benefits

• Parental Leave and Adoption Assistance

• Voluntary coverage options:

• Life Insurance

• Critical Illness

• Accident

• Identity Theft Protection

• Retiree medical benefits available for Medicare-eligible retirees

• 401(k) with company match

• Generous Paid Time Off and Company Holiday Schedule

• Collaborative, continuing education focused work environment

• Career advancement opportunities